Prowadź swój pług przez kości umarłych
- Downloads：8049
- Type：Epub+TxT+PDF+Mobi
- Create Date：2021-06-18 09:53:20
- Update Date：2025-09-06
- Status：finish
- Author：Olga Tokarczuk
- ISBN：8308060587
- Environment：PC/Android/iPhone/iPad/Kindle
- Download
Summary
Inspirująca， głośno dyskutowana powieść。 Thriller moralny z metafizyczną zagadką， zaskakującą pod każdym względem。
Zimą piękna Kotlina Kłodzka jest miejscem mało przyjaznym i opustoszałym。 Wsród nielicznych mieszkańców pozostała Janina Duszejko - miłośniczka astrologii， która w wolnych chwilach dogląda domów nieobecnych sąsiadów i tłumaczy poezję Blake'a。 Niespodziewanie przez tę spokojną okolicę przetacza się fala morderstw， których ofiarami padają myśliwi。 Czy to możliwe， by - jak sugeruje Duszejko - to zwierzęta zaczęły czyhać na życie swoich oprawców？ Wszak Blake pisał: "Błąkająca się Sarna po lesie / Ludzkiej Duszy niepokój niesie"。。。
Zimą piękna Kotlina Kłodzka jest miejscem mało przyjaznym i opustoszałym。 Wsród nielicznych mieszkańców pozostała Janina Duszejko - miłośniczka astrologii， która w wolnych chwilach dogląda domów nieobecnych sąsiadów i tłumaczy poezję Blake'a。 Niespodziewanie przez tę spokojną okolicę przetacza się fala morderstw， których ofiarami padają myśliwi。 Czy to możliwe， by - jak sugeruje Duszejko - to zwierzęta zaczęły czyhać na życie swoich oprawców？ Wszak Blake pisał: "Błąkająca się Sarna po lesie / Ludzkiej Duszy niepokój niesie"。。。
Reviews
Snem
，
Janina is a wonderfully eccentric character and I enjoyed seeing how she interacts with the world。 It’s a dark book and full of death in a beautifully bleak setting。 A solid murder mystery with lovely descriptions of nature。 I liked the Blake references， particularly this killer title。 I’m a sucker for a great title！ There were a few moments where the almost fairy-tale tone made me lose the plot。 I think Janina is a polarizing character and you will either like her or hate her and that could dic Janina is a wonderfully eccentric character and I enjoyed seeing how she interacts with the world。 It’s a dark book and full of death in a beautifully bleak setting。 A solid murder mystery with lovely descriptions of nature。 I liked the Blake references， particularly this killer title。 I’m a sucker for a great title！ There were a few moments where the almost fairy-tale tone made me lose the plot。 I think Janina is a polarizing character and you will either like her or hate her and that could dictate your enjoyment of this book。 It’s unconventional but compelling。 It’s sort of like if the cozy detective mystery took a wrong turn and ended up in Poland。 I had high expectations and some were not met， but in general it’s good。 。。。more
Sebastian Egan
，
Great book， interesting twist and makes you think about things you wouldn't normally。 Great book， interesting twist and makes you think about things you wouldn't normally。 。。。more
Tracey
，
I do not understand how this book won a Nobel Prize。 The end。
Javier Alemán
，
Un libro mestizo que junta tantas cosas que a veces parece costumbrista y a veces es tremendamente febril。 Aunque uno ya puede sospechar la resolución del principal misterio a mitad de la novela， me parece genial cómo la autora gestiona la expectativa y juega al despiste， el uso elegante que hace de la voz de la narradora y ese mundo rural que muestra que es de todo menos idílico。 Ideal para mostrar cómo se puede construir un thriller casi mágico sin recurrir a los tropos más manidos del género。
José Miguel Molina
，
Excelente forma de describir el lugar， los personajes y además de jugar con la mente del lector。No le doy 5 estrellas porque hubo pequeñas cosas que tal vez no me gustaron pero se las merece si yo no fuera tan quisquilloso。
Verônica Batista
，
Eu não tinha me envolvido com a leitura， até agora não sei se me envolvi， mas as resenhas que li sobre a história me fizeram gostar mais do livro do que gostei quando terminei。
Luana Togni
，
entendi a filosofia do livro， mas arrastado e detalhista demais。
Jennifer Hayward
，
This review has been hidden because it contains spoilers。 To view it， click here。 Read 50% but just could not。 Too much time spent talking about horoscopes and how they influence decisions。 Lady lives in a remote village and is convinced animals are working together to kill people in acts of revenge。
Deborah Levine
，
This was a slow read for me because the narrator's "voice" was so unlike anything I've ever read before， but I appreciated the immersive worlds （interior and exterior） the author created。 I can't begin to imagine how she came up with all of the depth and details。 I was surprised by the ending （the solution to the mystery） but didn't find it satisfying。 Still would recommend for those looking for something quite unique。 This was a slow read for me because the narrator's "voice" was so unlike anything I've ever read before， but I appreciated the immersive worlds （interior and exterior） the author created。 I can't begin to imagine how she came up with all of the depth and details。 I was surprised by the ending （the solution to the mystery） but didn't find it satisfying。 Still would recommend for those looking for something quite unique。 。。。more
Vicky
，
It's a 3。5/5 for me。 This is honestly the most interesting book I've ever read。 Not only because of the plot but because of the representation。 Polish representation in literature is only seen when there is the mention of World War 2。 I was so glad to hear that FINALLY there is a book set in Poland that is not about World War 2。 It's about something completely different。 This book is thrilling， fun， and exciting。 Amazing writing。 I am definitely recommending this to anyone。 My compliments to the It's a 3。5/5 for me。 This is honestly the most interesting book I've ever read。 Not only because of the plot but because of the representation。 Polish representation in literature is only seen when there is the mention of World War 2。 I was so glad to hear that FINALLY there is a book set in Poland that is not about World War 2。 It's about something completely different。 This book is thrilling， fun， and exciting。 Amazing writing。 I am definitely recommending this to anyone。 My compliments to the chef （Olga Tokarczuk！） I am definitely going to pick up some of her other books。 。。。more
Tânia Dias
，
Faltam-me as palavras。。。 depois desta brilhante história， tenho a firme convicção que lerei toda a obra de Olga Tokarczuk。 🤍
LaVonne Hanlon
，
Lyrical and eerily beautiful！ I didn't want this book to end Lyrical and eerily beautiful！ I didn't want this book to end 。。。more
J。C。
，
3 1/2 stars。 I feel like I should mark this book as read twice because there are numerous pages I chose to reread because they were just that great。 Five stars for the writing （it felt like every sentence was crafted and labored over）， the mood， the main character， the narration， all that stuff。 The astrology sections really slowed my reading pace down because I find astrology to be confusing。 Unfortunately as a murder mystery， the book doesn't really work very well because。。。。（（DEFINITE SPOILER 3 1/2 stars。 I feel like I should mark this book as read twice because there are numerous pages I chose to reread because they were just that great。 Five stars for the writing （it felt like every sentence was crafted and labored over）， the mood， the main character， the narration， all that stuff。 The astrology sections really slowed my reading pace down because I find astrology to be confusing。 Unfortunately as a murder mystery， the book doesn't really work very well because。。。。（（DEFINITE SPOILER ALERT））（view spoiler）[。。。 if you have three people living alone on a plateau and one of them dies under suspicious circumstances， the other two are automatically the suspects。 As soon as the first chapter ended I assumed it was the narrator who killed him。 In the end I wish it was the animals that were the culprits responsible for killing these evil hunters， that would have been a really crazy and enjoyable twist。 This book is basically Fargo meets John Wick but Mr。 Wick is an elderly， astrology loving， PETA supporting， Polish lady （that is not meant to be an insulting description， I found her to be a delightful character！！）。 （hide spoiler）]I do look forward to reading other books by her in the future。 。。。more
melis
，
metin süne süne bir hal olmuş， öykü veya novella olsaydı diye düşünmeden edemedim。ilk kez olga tokarczuk okuyorum， okumaya başlamak için bu metnini seçmemin başlıca sebebiyse vegan olmam。 bunu yorumun devamında söyleyeceklerim sebebiyle belirtme gereği duyuyorum。 evet， kitaplar kaçınılmaz olarak belirli ideolojiler çerçevesinde， o ideolojileri şöyle ya da böyle "yansıtarak" yazılıyor， metnin okuru o ideolojiyle ilişki içerisinde / karşısında vb。 konumlandırma gayesi gütmesi de epey olası。 ancak， metin süne süne bir hal olmuş， öykü veya novella olsaydı diye düşünmeden edemedim。ilk kez olga tokarczuk okuyorum， okumaya başlamak için bu metnini seçmemin başlıca sebebiyse vegan olmam。 bunu yorumun devamında söyleyeceklerim sebebiyle belirtme gereği duyuyorum。 evet， kitaplar kaçınılmaz olarak belirli ideolojiler çerçevesinde， o ideolojileri şöyle ya da böyle "yansıtarak" yazılıyor， metnin okuru o ideolojiyle ilişki içerisinde / karşısında vb。 konumlandırma gayesi gütmesi de epey olası。 ancak， konu özellikle kurmaca metinler olduğunda okuru düşünmeye teşvik etmek ile okura dışarıdan fikir aşılamak （hatta bu fikirleri okurun üstüne boca etmek） arasındaki farkın daha da büyüdüğünü， belirginleştiğini düşünüyorum。 okura düşünmesi için alan açmak ve okurun varması gerektiği düşünülen bir nokta varsa ona olabildiğince kendi kendine， kendi çıkarımlarıyla varmasını sağlamak gerekiyor， okura ne düşüneceğini söylemek değil。 okur kitlenizin veya ortalama bir okurun o "varılması gereken nokta"ya varamayacağını düşünerek böylesine kör göze bir üslupla yazıyorsanız bu okuru hafife almak gibi geliyor bana。 ayrıca bu "aşılanacak fikirler"i uzun uzun， tüm detaylarıyla çekiştirip sunabileceğiniz kurmaca dışı türlere yönelmek mümkün。 kısacası， fikirlerim metinle uyuştuğunda bile kurmaca bir metnin bana ne düşüneceğimi söylemesini istemiyorum。bunun dışında， karakter yaratımı kötü （yok？）， hikâye epey sarkıp sünüyor， anlatı meh， teknik yokuş aşağı yuvarlanıyor。 kitabın sonundaki anlatıcı "açıklama"sı yine kör göze parmak bir teknik， türlerle veya direkt tekniğin kendisiyle oynanmıyorsa （ki bazen oynansa bile） kullanılmaması taraftarıyım。metnin "içerik" kısmına gelince。 "hayvan tutkunu deli （ve yaşlı） kadın" imgesinin içi boşaltılacakmış gibi dururken aslında biraz daha doldurulmuş， anlatıcı karikatürleştirilmiş gibi geldi bana。 bu bile isteye yapılmış bir şeyse bile böyle olmamasını dilerdim elbette （ben de belirli ideolojiler çerçevesinde okuyorum， evet）。 başka temsiller mümkündü。 onun dışında， adalet ile intikam arayışı kol kola ilerliyor （ki bunda bir noktaya kadar sorun görmüyorum） ancak o "intikam" ancak kişisel boyutta ve ondan ibaret kalıyor， bu açıdan biraz "kahramanlık" anlatısına dönüştüğünü （veya en azından bunun izlerini taşıdığını） düşünüyorum metnin。 böylesine bir "mesaj kaygısı" gütmüş bir metnin intikam anlatısı ve kişisele hapsolmak yerine sisteme ve kolektifliğe biraz daha işaret edebilmesini beklerdim açıkçası。 son söylediğim iki şeyle bağlantılı olarak， anlatıcının her ne sebeple olsun "bilinçli olarak yapmadım" ve "ben sadece aracıyım" gibi sözler sarf etmesinin （veya bunların ardına saklanmasının） da metni （ve "mesaj"ını） zedelediğini düşünüyorum。 。。。more
Kelli Pullisaar
，
Eksistentsiaalseid küsimusi lahkav müstiline ökotriller。 Kas raamatut on paslik nimetada sümpaatseks， ma pole kindel， kuid selline tunne valdas mind raamatu lugemise ajal。 Sarnaneb meeleolult Tsõngõz Ajtmatovi teosele “Ja sajandist on pikem päev”。
Luís Santos
，
3，5☆Overall， an interesting story。 The plot and characters。 The struggles。 That ending was everything tho
Alicja
，
4⭐️
Dora
，
Está muy bien。
Rose López
，
Acudí a este libro después de que la autora ganara el Nobel y por la fama que tenía。 Tal vez me creé demasiadas expectativas y por eso me decepcionó。 Creo que el mensaje ecologista se presenta de una forma demasiado simple。 La sensación de Dejà Vu no desaparece según se resuelven los misterios， pero lo peor es， en mi opinión， que el discurso principal del libro， aquél por el que ha alcanzado fama， no se expone conforme a se espera de un premio Nobel， sino de una forma basada en lugares comunes， Acudí a este libro después de que la autora ganara el Nobel y por la fama que tenía。 Tal vez me creé demasiadas expectativas y por eso me decepcionó。 Creo que el mensaje ecologista se presenta de una forma demasiado simple。 La sensación de Dejà Vu no desaparece según se resuelven los misterios， pero lo peor es， en mi opinión， que el discurso principal del libro， aquél por el que ha alcanzado fama， no se expone conforme a se espera de un premio Nobel， sino de una forma basada en lugares comunes， fácil。 。。。more
Suzy Forman
，
While ultimately I'm probably closer to a 4。5， this book had so many 5-star elements for me that this rating only felt right。 Stunning writing—poetry in novel form。 The author picks out both the beauty and the stark normalities of everyday life in a way that makes you rethink them。 When the moments strike， however， she soars far into the world of strange and you don't need to think twice about looking back。 Janina's narration is often laugh-out-loud funny and just as often eerie。 If you want to While ultimately I'm probably closer to a 4。5， this book had so many 5-star elements for me that this rating only felt right。 Stunning writing—poetry in novel form。 The author picks out both the beauty and the stark normalities of everyday life in a way that makes you rethink them。 When the moments strike， however， she soars far into the world of strange and you don't need to think twice about looking back。 Janina's narration is often laugh-out-loud funny and just as often eerie。 If you want to get completely lost inside the thoughts of a character while simultaneously never quite knowing where her head is， this is the book for you。 。。。more
Becky
，
I read this book for my Mystery Book Club。 The author is a Nobel prize winner in literature。 Indeed， there are some beautiful sentences buried in this odd story。 One example: “Low dark clouds had been scudding across the sky all day， and now， late in the evening， they were rubbing their wet bellies against the hills。” But I almost gave up on the book， half way through。 The astrology didn’t interest me， the story dragged， the main character and setting were dreary。 I’m glad I trudged through to t I read this book for my Mystery Book Club。 The author is a Nobel prize winner in literature。 Indeed， there are some beautiful sentences buried in this odd story。 One example: “Low dark clouds had been scudding across the sky all day， and now， late in the evening， they were rubbing their wet bellies against the hills。” But I almost gave up on the book， half way through。 The astrology didn’t interest me， the story dragged， the main character and setting were dreary。 I’m glad I trudged through to the end， though， because there was quite a surprise twist （albeit from an unreliable narrator）。 。。。more
Ben
，
It was a quirky and interesting read told from the perspective of a character that， in most other narratives， would've only been described in a fleeting moment as she was passed by on the street。 Instead of just being the crazy old lady who cares too much about animals， Mrs。 Duszejko strategically positions herself to be at the center of understanding why the local wildlife has been linked to the string of surprising deaths nearby。 Her meddling and persistent wit drive this plow， page by page， l It was a quirky and interesting read told from the perspective of a character that， in most other narratives， would've only been described in a fleeting moment as she was passed by on the street。 Instead of just being the crazy old lady who cares too much about animals， Mrs。 Duszejko strategically positions herself to be at the center of understanding why the local wildlife has been linked to the string of surprising deaths nearby。 Her meddling and persistent wit drive this plow， page by page， like a knife through butter。 。。。more
Jaime
，
It’s been a long time since I’ve read a book that changes the way I think。 Not because it presented me with new information， but because it took information I process every day and cast it in a new light。 This book rocked me， made me feel like “I’m not the only one” and will now be on me “re read annually” list。
Beth Culp
，
*This review is for the audiobook*Had this recommended by a friend and was really impressed with how deep this book was。Part mystery， part fairy tale， Tokarczuk weaves a story that celebrates the Polish culture and the importance of listening。 While I feel like the way matters were handled was somewhat extreme， it speaks to the need to take heed of our elders and respect the land we are on。And evidently， there is trust to be found in our horoscopes。
Roberto Ruiz
，
It's a great story with a tremendous plot twist but most of all， the main character is so funny and adorable。 As a reader you empathize with her inmediatly and its really fun and interesting going through the story with her thoughts。 It's a great story with a tremendous plot twist but most of all， the main character is so funny and adorable。 As a reader you empathize with her inmediatly and its really fun and interesting going through the story with her thoughts。 。。。more
Paulo Henrique Oliveira
，
Não é como se eu fosse um grande literato ou um leitor voraz， mas esse foi um dos melhores livros que já li na vida。 A leveza da escrita， a personalidade única da protagonista-narradora e sua visão de mundo são alguns dos pontos fortes do livro。 Recomendadíssimo pra todos， principalmente pra quem está feito um zumbi nesse nosso dia-a-dia de déjà vu。
Noah
，
She’s got a voice like no other， she’s my mother！ It manages to be biting， gloriously funny， and humorously gory。 Creeps in slowly， like a draft at first。 Or what’s that old analogy？ Ah yes: the frog in the pot of water as it slowly boils to death。 Or a virus。 A bug creeps in and you don’t notice it until death is at your door。 And， then and only then， will He ask you if you will let Him in。 And you will have to choose。
Mela Pomme
，
Une écriture fine et poétique。 Un univers froid et contemplatif。 L'intrigue se tricote difficilement mais le dénouement est intéressant。 La synchronicité entre astrologie， animisme et faits divers est également très belle。 Une écriture fine et poétique。 Un univers froid et contemplatif。 L'intrigue se tricote difficilement mais le dénouement est intéressant。 La synchronicité entre astrologie， animisme et faits divers est également très belle。 。。。more
Maureen Holloway
，
I read this because of its prize winning reputation。 I had to skip much of the Astrological wordy paragraphs。 The main character is interesting， but not enough to win the big prizes this book has won。The philosophical musings are sometimes worth reading and thinking about。 However， there’s an unevenness about these。 There’s some good humor， too， but overall I’d say it’s an unusual and somewhat unsatisfying novel。
Stephanie
，